How RAP and IBR differ
Which plans you can choose depends on when your loans were made; student loan repayment plans in 2026 lists every plan and who can use it.
Both RAP and IBR set the payment from income and forgive what's left after enough qualifying payments, but almost every detail differs:
| RAP | IBR | |
|---|---|---|
| Payment | 1% to 10% of your whole AGI (by bracket) ÷ 12, minus $50 per dependent | 10% or 15% of AGI above 150% of the poverty guideline ÷ 12 |
| Minimum | $10 a month | $0 below a $5 calculated payment; $10 from $5 |
| Cap | None | The 10-year standard payment when you entered IBR |
| Unpaid interest | Waived on on-time payments | Charged, except for the first three years on subsidized loans; added to the balance when the payment reaches the cap or you leave IBR |
| Principal | Matched up to $50 a month | No match |
| Forgiveness | After 360 payments (30 years) | After 240 (new borrowers since July 1, 2014) or 300 payments |
| Family | $50 off per tax dependent | Poverty guideline for your whole family size |
| Who can use it | Everyone with eligible loans | Only loans made before July 1, 2026 |
When RAP tends to win
- You will pay the loan off. With no interest growth and a monthly principal match, every on-time payment shrinks the balance. On the calculator's starting example, a single borrower earning $55,000 with $35,000 at 6.52%, RAP starts at $229.17 a month against IBR's $258.83 and pays the loan off in 162 months instead of 172.
- Your income sits just below a bracket edge. RAP charges one percentage across each $10,000 band, so it compares best with IBR near the top of a band, before the next edge raises the rate.
- You want the balance to fall. With on-time RAP payments it drops every month; under IBR a small payment can let unpaid interest pile up for years.
When IBR tends to win
- Large balances. IBR forgives after 20 or 25 years, RAP after 30. For a borrower with $220,000 at 7.05% and $68,000 of AGI, the calculator shows RAP running the full 360 payments while IBR reaches forgiveness at 240. That costs roughly $211,000 in total under IBR, including the estimated tax, against about $343,000 under RAP.
- Low incomes. IBR can be $0; RAP never goes below $10. At $22,000 of AGI, IBR's payment is $0 and RAP's is $36.67.
- Families. IBR's deduction grows with family size (150% of $5,680 for each extra person in the 48 states in 2026). RAP takes a flat $50 a month per dependent.
- Higher incomes with a balance that stays high. IBR's payment is capped at your 10-year standard amount; RAP has no cap.
- Fewer working years left. RAP forgives after 30 years, IBR after 20 or 25. Enter your age under "More details" to see the age each plan would end at.
Many results are close, and they are sensitive to raises and family changes. Change the inputs and watch the order.
What people miss before choosing
These are the points borrowers most often get wrong, each checked against the regulations (34 CFR 685.209, 685.211 and 685.219):
- RAP months don't count toward IBR. Your IBR payments, and payments under PAYE, ICR or SAVE before July 1, 2028, count toward RAP's 360. It doesn't work the other way. If you later move from RAP to IBR, months paid on RAP don't count toward IBR's 20 or 25 years, unless a payment was at least the 10-year standard amount or was a qualifying PSLF payment. You can change plans at any time, but that clock doesn't come with you. If your servicer shows all 360 RAP payments still to go after you switch, ask it to apply the earlier months that count.
- Deferments count differently. On IBR, months in a cancer treatment, unemployment, economic hardship, military service or rehabilitation deferment count toward forgiveness. On RAP, only unemployment and economic hardship deferment months count toward the 360, and while you are on RAP no deferment month counts toward PSLF. If you expect a long deferment, for example during cancer treatment, weigh that before switching.
- The lower payment can let the balance balloon. Take $45,000 at 6% with an AGI of $25,000 and no dependents, on old IBR. IBR starts at $13.25 a month and RAP at $41.67. Under IBR the unpaid interest builds up: with a 3% yearly raise, the balance reaches about $98,400 by forgiveness after 25 years. Under RAP it falls every month, and about $24,700 is forgiven after 30 years. At a 22% tax rate IBR still costs less in total here, about $35,700 against $49,300, but its tax bill at forgiveness is about $21,700 against $5,400.
- The "tax bomb". Forgiveness after 20, 25 or 30 years counts as federal income in the year it happens, because the exclusion for forgiven student loans ended on December 31, 2025. A large forgiven balance is taxed on top of that year's income. A borrower who is insolvent at that moment may be able to exclude some or all of it (IRS Publication 4681). PSLF forgiveness is not taxed.
- Old IBR or new IBR. New IBR, 10% of income above 150% of the poverty guideline for 20 years, is for borrowers who had no federal loan balance before July 1, 2014. Everyone else is on old IBR, 15% for 25 years. The calculator's "New IBR" box switches between them.
- RAP has no cap and no $0. IBR's payment never goes above the 10-year standard amount set when you entered IBR, and it can be $0. RAP's payment keeps rising with your income and never goes below $10.
- RAP's brackets don't move with inflation. They are fixed dollar amounts, so ordinary raises push you into higher percentages. At $46,000 of AGI RAP is 4%, or $153.33 a month; at $55,000 it is 5%, or $229.17. Pre-tax 401(k) or 403(b) contributions lower your AGI, and near a bracket edge they can drop you a whole percentage. Enter an amount under "Extra pre-tax savings" in the calculator to see what more would do.
- Late payments cost twice on RAP. A late payment gets no interest waiver or principal match, and it doesn't count toward the 360, which counts only on-time RAP payments. IBR counts any payment of the amount due. PSLF also counts only on-time RAP payments, so a late one costs a PSLF month too.
- Extra payments mostly pay waived interest. Payments go to interest first. While your RAP payment is below the month's interest, extra money pays interest that would have been waived and shrinks the principal match. How the waiver and match work explains when extra money starts to help.
- A new loan, even a consolidation, closes IBR. Any Direct Loan made on or after July 1, 2026, including a Direct Consolidation Loan, limits all your loans to RAP or the Tiered Standard plan. Going back to school or consolidating now means giving up IBR and the older fixed plans.
- Leaving IBR goes through Standard. If you leave IBR, you move onto the standard plan, recalculated over what is left of its 10 years, or onto RAP. After one standard payment you can change to any other plan you're eligible for.
- Your payment follows the tax return on file. The servicer uses the AGI on your latest return, or the income documents you give it, for 12 months at a time. A raise shows up at the first recertification that uses a tax return including it. If your income drops, you can ask for a recalculation sooner.
If you're on PAYE
PAYE stays open to borrowers already on it until June 30, 2028. Its payment is the same as new IBR's: 10% of income above 150% of the poverty guideline, never more than the 10-year standard amount, and it forgives after 240 payments (34 CFR 685.209(f)(2), (k)(2)). PAYE months count toward RAP's 360 and toward IBR forgiveness, so leaving PAYE for either plan keeps your count.
So RAP vs PAYE is mostly RAP vs new IBR. To see what PAYE charges, tick "New IBR" in the calculator: the IBR row then uses PAYE's formula. The IBR calculator shows each step of it. The difference is time. PAYE ends in 2028, and anyone still on it then is moved to RAP, or to IBR for loans RAP can't take. If you had a federal loan balance before July 1, 2014, your IBR after PAYE would be old IBR, 15% for 25 years.
The fixed plans in the comparison
Besides RAP and IBR, borrowers whose loans were all made before July 1, 2026 can choose plans that repay the loan in full on a schedule (34 CFR 685.208):
- 10-year Standard: the same payment for 10 years, at least $50 a month.
- Graduated: payments start lower and rise, usually every two years, over up to 10 years. No payment may be less than the month's interest or more than three times any other. The calculator's schedule follows those rules and starts as low as they allow; your servicer sets the real steps.
- Extended: for borrowers with more than $30,000 of Direct Loans, fixed or graduated payments over up to 25 years, at least $50 a month. These have the lowest payments of the fixed plans and cost the most interest.
- Tiered Standard: for anyone with a loan made on or after July 1, 2026, over 10 to 25 years depending on the balance.
None of these forgive anything. The older plans' payments count toward PSLF or income-driven forgiveness only in months when they are at least the 10-year standard amount. Tiered Standard payments never count toward PSLF, but on-time ones always count toward RAP's 360. Their terms also run from when your loans entered repayment, not from today, so a borrower who has been repaying for years has less time left and a higher payment. Enter your months in repayment under "More details"; a plan whose term has run out can't be chosen.
If you're pursuing PSLF
With Public Service Loan Forgiveness, what's left after 120 qualifying payments is forgiven tax-free. So the plan with the lower payments usually costs less, and both RAP and IBR count (RAP payments when they are on time). Tick "Working toward PSLF" to see it, or use the PSLF calculator for the month of your 120th payment and what a buyback would change.
Medical residents and other low-income, high-balance years
Borrowers who earn little now and much more later, such as residents, fellows or early-career lawyers, face the widest gap. At a resident's income, both RAP and IBR payments are small compared with the interest. RAP waives that interest while IBR lets it accrue, and IBR forgives a decade sooner. The right answer usually turns on PSLF: with PSLF, the lower payment usually costs less; without it, IBR's earlier forgiveness competes with RAP's falling balance.
A yearly raise can't show a jump from a resident's pay to an attending's. Under "More details", enter the later income as "AGI after a big change" and the year it starts. Take a resident earning $65,000 with $300,000 of loans at 7.5% who expects about $250,000 from year 4:
- With the raise alone, the calculator would show RAP forgiving about $282,000 after 30 years and IBR about $636,500 after 20. That isn't what happens on an attending's pay.
- With the income change, RAP pays the loan off in 248 payments, for about $581,100. IBR costs about $555,300, including an estimated $52,400 of tax on about $238,000 forgiven after 20 years. The 10-year Standard plan costs the least, about $427,300, but it asks $3,561.06 a month from the first month.
- With PSLF, IBR costs about $184,800 over the 120 payments and RAP about $203,600.
What the comparison assumes
Payments are on time; the rate is fixed; income rises by your expected raise each year, or changes in the year you enter under "AGI after a big change", and payments are recalculated yearly; the poverty guidelines grow with the inflation input; dependents and a spouse's loan share stay as entered; there are no deferments or forbearances. IBR's extra interest help on subsidized loans in the first three years isn't modeled. Totals are in plain dollars; enter a rate under "Totals in today's dollars" to also see each plan's total with later payments discounted, which matters when one plan pays for years longer than another. Your servicer's numbers decide. The sources and methods page lists every rule.
Common questions
Is RAP or IBR better?
It depends on your income, balance and family. RAP usually has the lower payment for middle incomes and helps borrowers who will pay the loan off, because it waives unpaid interest and matches principal. IBR forgives after 20 or 25 years instead of 30 and can be $0 at low incomes, so it often costs less in total for large balances. Run both above on your numbers.
Is RAP an income-driven repayment plan?
Yes. Like IBR, PAYE and ICR, RAP sets the payment from your income and forgives what's left after enough qualifying payments, and all of them are in the same federal rule, 34 CFR 685.209. RAP is the only income-driven plan open to a borrower with a Direct Loan made on or after July 1, 2026. PAYE and ICR remain only for borrowers already on them, until July 1, 2028, and SAVE ended by court judgment on March 10, 2026.
Can I choose IBR after July 1, 2026?
Only for loans made before July 1, 2026, and only if you have no Direct Loan made on or after that date. A borrower who made 60 or more qualifying payments under SAVE on or after July 1, 2024 can't enroll in IBR.
What is the difference between old IBR and new IBR?
New borrowers, meaning those with no federal loan balance before July 1, 2014, pay 10% of their income above 150% of the poverty guideline and get forgiveness after 20 years. Everyone else pays 15% and waits 25 years. Both are capped at the 10-year standard payment.
Do RAP and IBR both count toward PSLF?
Yes. Both are qualifying repayment plans for Public Service Loan Forgiveness. With PSLF the plan with the lower payments usually costs less, because the balance left after 120 payments is forgiven tax-free.
Can I switch between RAP and IBR later?
Yes. A borrower on an income-driven plan can change at any time to any plan they are eligible for. Moving from IBR to RAP keeps your IBR payments, which count toward RAP's 360, but leaving IBR adds its unpaid interest to your balance. Moving from RAP to IBR is allowed if you can still use IBR, but months paid on RAP don't count toward IBR's 20 or 25 years unless a payment was at least the 10-year standard amount or was a qualifying PSLF payment.
What is the student loan tax bomb?
It is the federal income tax on a balance forgiven after 20, 25 or 30 years of income-driven payments. Since January 1, 2026 the forgiven amount counts as income in the year it is forgiven, on top of your other income. A borrower who is insolvent at that moment may be able to exclude some or all of it (IRS Publication 4681). PSLF forgiveness is not taxed.